I don’t know about you, but the first place I always look for easy recipe inspiration is Pinterest. With the holiday season upon us, it’s safe to assume that Christmas cookie recipes are a hot topic on everyone’s minds. So which cookie reigns supreme? Whether you are baking cookies for a cookie swap or for a fun and festive holiday dessert to serve next to the Christmas tree, finding the best Christmas cookie recipe is a rather daunting task.
There’s thousands of different cookie dough recipes that would be the perfect addition on any Christmas party. From little snowballs, sugar cookies, chocolate chip cookies, ginger cookies and gingerbread cookies, there’s a bound to be a favorite cookie for everyone.
This past year, Pinterest took a look at its analytics and found out which Christmas cookie was the most pinned on their site. In between the recipes for chocolate cookies, peanut butter cookies and candy cane cookies, I was shocked when I found out what the recipe was.
Assuming it was going to be something trendy like shortbread cookies or classic sugar cookies, I was surprised that the best Christmas cookie was actually a buttery jam thumbprint cookies recipe. Who would have thought this simple cookie would be the hit at the cookie exchange?
How to Make Buttery Jam Thumbprints
Amy, the blogger behind Chew Out Loud, first tasted these cookies over 10 years ago at a friend’s house. Immediately she grabbed a piece of paper and jotted down the recipe.
This great recipe makes the perfect butter cookie. Not too sweet, not too savory–it’s just right.Begin by creaming the butter and sugar in an electric mixer until light and fluffy then add in the salt and vanilla. Stir in the flour until a soft cookie dough forms then place in the fridge to chill for about 30 minutes.
Once the dough is firmed, roll the cookie dough into balls and indent each ball with your finger. Fill with your favorite jam and bake until nice and puffy. Dust with powdered sugar and serve with milk. Santa will thank you for making the perfect cookie.